UEL English PEN Society Book Reviews

I’m sure we all know the story from the books or the films, however I am only reading the books for the first time and I have completely fallen in love with the series. For those of you that have only watched the films, read the books! Being a Tolkien fan I used to criticise Rowling as a poor imitation, now I’ve read the books I realise that perhaps Steve Kloves (who wrote the screenplay for all eight films) failed to capture the distinct differences between the authors’ works.
This book was by far the most emotional of the series so far in my opinion (I still have two to read). I had to put the book down every few paragraphs because I couldn’t see through the tears after the return from the Ministry of Magic. The thing I love most about this series is the way the writing style matures with the characters and the readers; it really does encourage children to continue reading into adulthood. Again read it or read it again; Rowling has a fan for life in me.

Helen

I’m sure we all know the story from the books or the films, however I am only reading the books for the first time and I have completely fallen in love with the series. For those of you that have only watched the films, read the books! Being a Tolkien fan I used to criticise Rowling as a poor imitation, now I’ve read the books I realise that perhaps Steve Kloves (who wrote the screenplay for all eight films) failed to capture the distinct differences between the authors’ works.
This was my favourite film in the series, and so far it is my favourite book too. Again so much detail was lost when it was made into a film (like why Fleur didn’t have an accent in The Deathly Hallows). Rowling once again exceeded my expectations with this book and where I could never understand the fandom before I thoroughly can now. Again read this book, or read it again.

Helen

I’m sure we all know the story from the books or the films, however I am only reading the books for the first time and I have completely fallen in love with the series. For those of you that have only watched the films, read the books! Being a Tolkien fan I used to criticise Rowling as a poor imitation, now I’ve read the books I realise that perhaps Steve Kloves (who wrote the screenplay for all eight films) failed to capture the distinct differences between the authors’ works.
As for this book; words escape me. Not my favourite of the series, but still it has an amazing story and had me truly empathising with the characters. There is so much detail that was not included within the film, it is a must read. And if you’ve already read it, read it again.

Helen